Spokane Judge Fennessy unseated by court of appeals attorney after eight years

Andrew Van Winkle's victory over incumbent Spokane Superior Court Judge Timothy Fennessy in the 2024 election has sent ripples through the local judicial landscape. Fennessy, who had previously unseated an incumbent eight years ago, graciously acknowledged the honor of serving the community in his farewell message. Van Winkle, who has extensive legal experience, including roles in the Washington Legislature and as a deputy prosecutor, highlighted strategic campaigning as a key to his success. His campaign not only focused on his qualifications but also on articulating a compelling reason for change, particularly advocating for reforms in the treatment of mental health issues in court. He aims to modernize court processes by promoting electronic submissions of legal documents, which he believes will enhance access to justice for community members.

Legal experts note that such a defeat of an incumbent is unusual, as sitting judges typically enjoy a significant advantage during elections. This election outcome reflects broader trends in judicial elections where challengers can successfully unseat incumbents by effectively communicating their vision for change. Van Winkle's commitment to improving the judicial system resonates with a growing public desire for more accessible and responsive legal processes.