Hearing Examiner Decision Re Gardenia Plat

The Bonney Lake Hearing Examiner dismissed an appeal on February 26, 2025, related to a tree removal permit for the Gardenia Plat, located near Myers Road and 77th Street East. The appeal was filed by individuals against the permit, but the developer successfully requested its dismissal. This ruling signifies a significant step forward for the development, although the city has stated that the permit will not be issued until the appeal window closes. The Hearing Examiner, who operates independently, serves to provide fair judgments on administrative land-use decisions. Importantly, the Bonney Lake City Council does not participate in such permit decisions, maintaining a clear separation of powers.

The decision also opens the door for those involved in the appeal to contest the ruling in Pierce County Superior Court. As the situation remains legally sensitive, the city has opted not to comment further. This case highlights ongoing tensions between development interests and community concerns regarding land use.