SJ leaders reject stronger police oversight despite independent auditors call for more

San Jose city officials voted against Independent Police Auditor Eddie Aubrey's proposal to review all use-of-force incidents, which would enhance police oversight in the community. A recent report indicated that out of 400 total incidents in 2024, 13 resulted in serious injuries, highlighting the risk involved in police actions. The City Council cited budget constraints and resource limitations as reasons for rejecting the proposal, despite Aubrey's call for more comprehensive oversight. Councilmember Rosemary Kamei expressed concern that strengthening the IPA's office could overburden its resources. Police Chief Paul Joseph defended the current system, stating that laws requiring timely public access to body camera footage ensure transparency.

However, Aubrey noted his office struggles with access to critical evidence, delaying investigations. The council also dismissed a request for equal access to officer-involved shooting materials. Advocates maintain that expanding the auditor's review scope is essential for building community trust and accountability.