Chief Bill Scott took on the difficult task of transforming a beleaguered SFPD. Did he deliver?

Chief Bill Scott will depart from the San Francisco Police Department in June, concluding an eight-year tenure characterized by attempts at reform amid ongoing community unrest. He implemented policies that reduced police shootings by half and emphasized de-escalation, but critics argue that systemic issues remain unaddressed. Former police commissioner Angela Chan highlighted the department's “substantially compliant” status, yet she and others believe that police violence continues disproportionately. Scott's leadership has been a balancing act, attempting to satisfy both community advocates and police unions resistant to change. His efforts included new policies to limit minor traffic stops, which disproportionately affect people of color.

Despite challenges, crime rates in San Francisco are at historic lows, illustrating the impact of some reforms. Scott's next role will be leading the newly formed transit cops division at LA Metro, marking a significant career transition. His departure comes as the city shifts towards a more law-and-order approach under new leadership.