Wiener Trump's Alcatraz Idea 'Absurd,' Would Be 'Domestic Gulag In the Middle of San Francisco Bay'

Trump proposed on Truth Social that Alcatraz be reopened as a federal prison for "the most dangerous criminals," igniting immediate backlash from local officials. California Governor Gavin Newsom dismissed the idea as a distraction, while House Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi emphasized Alcatraz's status as a national park and tourist destination. State Senator Scott Wiener described the proposal as "absurd," noting its economic significance in generating revenue and supporting jobs. Experts, including Alcatraz historian John Martini, highlighted the impracticality of the plan, citing the site's decay and the high costs associated with its transformation. The federal prison population has been increasing since 2022, contradicting Trump's claims about crime and incarceration rates.

Trump's suggestion aligns with his history of provocative statements aimed at liberal audiences. The criticism reflects broader concerns about his influence on public discourse and policy. As the backlash unfolds, many wonder if this proposal will fade from the national conversation as quickly as it emerged.