BART plazas lack of housing, retail doomed 16th and Mission long ago, veteran cop says

The panel discussion on the challenges facing the 16th Street BART plaza in San Francisco revealed deep-rooted issues of urban planning and community safety. Former police captain Al Casciato highlighted how the BART station's construction in the 1970s led to the decline of local businesses and a lack of housing and retail options. He emphasized that incorporating these elements could have provided a safer environment, aligning with urban planning principles advocated by Jane Jacobs. Local resident Rob Young shared his distressing experiences with drug use in the area, noting that the removal of encampments has not resolved the underlying issues of addiction and homelessness. Young expressed concern for his family's safety amid the ongoing drug activity, describing a "drug carnival" atmosphere in the alleyways.

Mayor Daniel Lurie's administration is now prioritizing a crackdown on the plaza's issues, with hopes for improved coordination among city departments. However, residents remain skeptical about the effectiveness of these measures. The conversation underscores the urgent need for a comprehensive plan to revitalize the area and support its residents.