Trump admin. fires S.F. immigration judge with high asylum rate

The Department of Justice dismissed Judge Chloe S. Dillon, noted for granting asylum in 96. 5% of her cases, the second-highest rate in San Francisco. This action follows the dismissal of four other immigration judges in the city, who similarly granted asylum at rates above the national average. The firings have sparked allegations of political motivation, especially under the Trump administration, which has removed over 50 immigration judges nationwide this year.

Critics highlight that Dillon's termination occurs despite her being outside the typical two-year probation period for judges. Dillon's courtroom witnessed the arrest of an asylum-seeker just days before her firing, illustrating the tense environment within immigration courts. Asylum-seekers often face arrest immediately after hearings, raising significant concerns about due process. The Justice Department has not commented on the firings, leaving many unanswered questions about the implications for immigration law. These developments highlight the ongoing challenges and controversies within the immigration court system, with a backlog of approximately 3.

5 million cases remaining unaddressed.