A 19-year-old in S.F. treatment program passed some notes. Now, he faces years in prison.

Alan Elizalde, a 19-year-old from San Francisco, may face a 12-year prison sentence after being discharged from a substance-use treatment program due to rule violations. His attorney received a letter stating Elizalde was removed for “behaviors detrimental to the program” and “non-compliance with program rules. ” The teenager had previously accepted a plea deal for robbery, which allowed for a reduced sentence if he successfully completed the treatment program. Elizalde's violations included using a cell phone and delivering notes to another resident, actions deemed “fraternizing. ” He faced serious felony charges stemming from a January 2024 crime spree involving armed robbery and carjacking.

Although he initially made progress toward sobriety, his infractions jeopardized his chance for a lighter sentence. This case raises critical questions about San Francisco's approach to crime and rehabilitation, especially as public safety remains a top concern. Advocates and family members are left to ponder what justice truly means in this context.