Jury tosses murder case, deadlocks on manslaughter charge in 2022 killing of Oakland homeless man

In a contentious trial, a jury has dismissed a second-degree murder case against Kevin Mak in the fatal stabbing of Chi Leung, a 66-year-old homeless man, while failing to reach a consensus on manslaughter charges. The jury deliberated for over three days, indicating the complexity of the evidence and arguments presented. Mak’s defense team contended that he acted in self-defense during a confrontation with Leung, which they argued was misinterpreted by prosecutors. The trial has underscored critical social issues, particularly the rising violence against the homeless and the challenges faced by vulnerable populations in urban settings. This case has sparked broader discussions on the legal definitions of self-defense and manslaughter, especially concerning actions taken in high-stress situations.

The partial verdict raises significant questions about accountability and the treatment of individuals in precarious circumstances. As the jury's decision is publicly scrutinized, it highlights the ongoing struggle between public safety and the rights of the homeless community. The outcome of this trial may influence future legal cases and public policies related to homelessness and urban violence.