Appeals court denies citys attempt to dismiss defamation lawsuit from fired Minneapolis officer

The Minnesota Court of Appeals ruled that Tyler Timberlake's defamation lawsuit against the city of Minneapolis and Police Chief Brian O’Hara can continue. Timberlake, who was fired following a controversial incident where he used a stun gun on an unarmed Black man, accused O'Hara of making defamatory statements in a bid to evade responsibility. The city claimed O'Hara's public comments were protected under "absolute privilege," arguing this immunity applies to high-level officials. However, the court determined that this privilege does not extend to a non-elected police chief, as noted by Judge Randall J. Slieter.

The ruling also reversed a previous finding that the city was immune from defamation lawsuits regarding Timberlake's termination letter. O'Hara's attorney argued that the statements were made during the course of his job duties and should be protected. Timberlake's attorney expressed satisfaction with the outcome, emphasizing the unnecessary delay caused by the city's legal maneuvers. The case highlights ongoing tensions surrounding police conduct and accountability in Minneapolis following high-profile incidents.