Former Auburn cop sentenced to 16 years, 8 months for murder

Jeffrey Nelson, a former Auburn Police Officer, received a sentence of 16 years and eight months for the second-degree murder of Jesse Sarey, who was shot in May 2019 while Nelson was on duty. The jury's conviction in June 2024 marked a pivotal moment in Washington state's legal landscape, as Nelson became the first officer convicted of murder under the standards set by Initiative 940, aimed at enhancing accountability for police officers. The sentencing occurred on January 23, 2025, in a courtroom filled with supporters and community members, reflecting the case's significant local impact. Judge Nicole Phelps noted that while Nelson's defense argued self-defense during a struggle, the officer had a duty to protect and serve, especially given Sarey's vulnerable state. The prosecution's recommendation for a longer sentence was based on Nelson's history and the tragic circumstances surrounding Sarey's death, including his struggles with homelessness and mental health issues.

Attendees at the sentencing included family members of Sarey, who spoke to the lasting impact of his death on their lives. This case continues to resonate within discussions on police accountability and the use of force in law enforcement. The outcome underscores the complexities and challenges faced in reforming police practices and ensuring justice for marginalized communities.