Appeals court rules San Diego's yoga ban is unconstitutional

The 9th U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that San Diego's prohibition on yoga classes in public parks is unconstitutional, reinforcing First Amendment protections. The court found that city officials did not provide any evidence linking yoga instruction to threats against public safety or enjoyment in parks. This ban arose from an amended ordinance that also restricted street vendors and required permits for commercial activities, including yoga classes with four or more participants.

Instructors Steven Hubbard and Amy Baack filed a lawsuit, arguing the enforcement of the ban violated their rights to free speech. Although a federal judge initially ruled in favor of the city, the appeals panel stated that "Teaching yoga is protected speech. " The city argued the ban was necessary for public safety, yet the court noted a lack of explanation for how yoga could lead to harmful consequences. A representative from the San Diego City Attorney's office mentioned they are evaluating the ruling and potential next steps. Hubbard and Baack have also filed a separate lawsuit regarding citations issued for livestreaming yoga classes from home.