Ald. Jim Gardiner Cleared Of Ethics Violation And 20K Fine We Went To War With The City

Alderman James Gardiner has been exonerated from a $20,000 fine after a hearing officer determined he did not breach the city's ethics ordinance concerning his treatment of critic Pete Czosnyka. Initially, the Board of Ethics ruled Gardiner committed 10 violations, but the hearing officer concluded that the city did not meet the burden of proof required for liability. During his emotional address to the City Council, Gardiner reflected on the profound impact the investigation had on his life, revealing feelings of devastation and depression. His defense highlighted testimony from former aides and new evidence that emerged during the appeal process. The inspector general's report had previously indicated that Gardiner used city resources to target Czosnyka, who had successfully defended his legal garden against city fines.

The Board of Ethics' unanimous vote to clear Gardiner emphasizes the ongoing scrutiny of political practices in local governance. Gardiner's case illustrates the challenges of public office and the potential for perceived misuse of authority. The incident raises questions about political accountability and the ethics of using municipal resources in personal disputes.